Blog
Embedded Files
Have you ever found yourself thinking (or saying) . . .
"He (or she) knows exactly what I'm asking him to do; he (she) just refuses."
"She can spend two hours working on something she enjoys, but the minute I announce that it's time for math or reading, everything falls apart."
"Soon after I give a consequence, the behavior gets worse."
"She talked about going to co-op all weekend. Then, when it was time to leave, she suddenly refused to get dressed."
For any parent, behaviors like these can be incredibly frustrating. When a child argues, negotiates, avoids, shuts down, runs away, becomes silly, changes the subject, or has an explosive reaction to a seemingly reasonable request, it is easy to arrive at one conclusion:
CATEGORIES
SIGN UP FOR BLOG UPDATES!
Join our email list to receive updates and information about our programs.
MOST RECENT POSTS
Defiance.
And sometimes, a child is testing a boundary or simply refuses to comply.
But sometimes there may be another explanation worth considering. For some neurodivergent children, particularly some children with autism or other neurodevelopmental conditions, what appears to be deliberate defiance may be connected to an increased response to demands and a strong need to maintain autonomy. This pattern is often discussed using the term PDA, or Pathological Demand Avoidance, sometimes described by advocates as Persistent Drive for Autonomy. Understanding this distinction matters because how we interpret behavior directly influences how we respond. And the wrong interpretation can lead us to use interventions and investments that unintentionally make the problem worse.
When the Ordinary Request Doesn't Feel Ordinary
Imagine saying:
To most of us, these are ordinary expectations. But a child experiencing significant demand-related anxiety or a threat to autonomy may experience those same words very differently. The problem may not simply be the task itself. The experience of being required to do it can become the trigger.
That helps explain one of the most confusing things parents sometimes observe:
The child may resist something they actually enjoy.
A child may love science experiments but refuse once the experiment becomes an assignment.
A teenager may enjoy writing stories but become unable to write when told, “You need to write a paragraph.”
A child may desperately want to attend an activity but become overwhelmed when it is time to get dressed and leave.
Behavior is Information
One of the most useful shifts we can make when supporting neurodivergent learners is moving from: "How do I stop this behavior?" to: "What might this behavior be communicating?"
This does not mean that every behavior should be excused.
It does not mean children should never have expectations, responsibilities, boundaries, or accountability.
And it certainly does not mean that every child who avoids schoolwork has PDA.
Instead, it means that effective intervention begins with accurately identifying the problem.
If I believe a child is refusing because they simply need stronger consequences, I will probably increase pressure.
But what happens if pressure is actually contributing to the child's dysregulation? That's right! I may unintentionally create a cycle.
The Demand-Avoidance Cycle
When pressure increases, so can avoidance.
Demand Avoidance Doesn't Always Look Like "No"
Avoidance can be surprisingly subtle. A child might negotiate endlessly, procrastinate, become silly, change the subject, ask repeated questions, suddenly need the bathroom, shut down, attempt to control exactly how something happens, or have an emotional outburst. Parents may also notice significant inconsistency.
“She did this yesterday. I know she can do it.” And academically, that may be true. But having a skill and being able to access that skill while dysregulated are not always the same thing. This is why understanding the circumstances surrounding the behavior is so important.
What Can Homeschool Parents Do?
If demands seem to contribute to your child's distress, try changing how you present expectations rather than simply removing them. Try offering meaningful choices, advance notice, collaborative problem-solving, extra processing time, flexible ways to demonstrate learning, and fewer unnecessary demands. The goal is not to trick a child into compliance. It is to create enough safety, autonomy, predictability, and collaboration that the child can access the skills you are trying to teach.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse